Home > Other - Politics Government > Does giving tax breaks to big companies result in more jobs and better health care?

Does giving tax breaks to big companies result in more jobs and better health care?

December 23rd, 2008 Leave a comment Go to comments
burtongrl asked:


Or can these companies hoard the money and offer minimal health benefits and salaries to workers if they want to? Does this ‘trickle down’ effect only work when the corporate big dogs are very ethical? In this case, wouldn’t giving tax breaks to the middle class be better?

  1. Forget War Buy More
    December 24th, 2008 at 21:10 | #1

    No, not at all.

    If that were the case wouldn’t things like water and sewage be privatized and taxed?

  2. Melting Media EAC
    December 27th, 2008 at 18:48 | #2

    The moment the tax cuts went into effect, my company began cutting jobs. I only survived because a regional vp saw my name on the list and lined it out, explaining I was valuable enough to keep.

    Part of the reason Bolivians swung to the left is due to being screwed by Bechtel getting the contract to privatize their water and sewerage.

    Yeah Kevin, health care is so good that every convenience store I go into has a jar collecting donations for a 2-year-old with leukemia whose family are part of the working poor and have no health care.

  3. Kevin B
    December 28th, 2008 at 14:13 | #3

    You got the jobs part right. Big Co.= Lots of jobs. The heath care? There is no better than American Health Care. So we are good there too.

  4. Farmer Jed
    December 31st, 2008 at 20:08 | #4

    Big companies hire LOTS of people.

    Offering them tax breaks helps to keep people employed. THAT is a good thing……………….

    I would much rather have my job than a $500 tax break.

  5. Jim H
    January 2nd, 2009 at 11:06 | #5

    maybe for people in India China, but no, not here. there are no ethical corporate big dogs,only lap dogs. and yes, I’d love a tax break!

  6. The 8 Bicycle and Jim
    January 2nd, 2009 at 14:53 | #6

    There is higher unemployment and more people without health insurance than ever since the Bush tax cuts.

  7. koffea
    January 5th, 2009 at 13:20 | #7

    it has meant exactly that for me. I saw a direct relation to my benefits package and salary increase when my local state lowered taxes pertaining to the corp i worke for. I would not say that they are necessarily ethical, but they had to do something to compete against other corp’s for talent and production.

    Generally speaking when companies have more money, they invest that money into their own growth which results in more jobs. their are exceptions to this of course, but for the vast majority of publicly traded companies this is true.

  8. JBish
    January 8th, 2009 at 19:44 | #8

    First of all the number of employees that make up small businesses throughout American greatly outweigh the number of people employed in big business America. Secondly, every small business owner the so called back of America will tell you that tax cuts allow employees benefits to rise or remain constant. Where as, tax increases raise the cost of hiring new employees and providing them with more and more benefits

  1. No trackbacks yet.